In the cosmic struggle between good and evil, Shakespeare presents the relentless conflict between two philosophies that shape the human condition.
The philosophy of Claudius, the usurping tyrant who secretly poisoned his brother King Hamlet and married his wife Queen Gertrude, assumes that might is right, man is a god, and the end justifies the means. The philosophy of Hamlet, the noble prince of Denmark, acknowledges that justice is divine and eternal in origin, that man is the servant and creature of God, and that one cannot do evil to achieve good. Claudius has no more qualms about killing Hamlet than in murdering the king. Suspicious that Hamlet knows the truth about the foul murder and wary by the danger Hamlet poses, Claudius schemes to send Hamlet to England under the pretext of a change of scenery to cure him of melancholy over his father's death. Traveling with two so-called former friends from the university, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, Hamlet discovers a packet of letters ordering his execution in England. Claudius, the master Machiavellian, plots, lies, and kills with the brutality of the lion and the cunning of the fox. He is the godlike arbiter of life and death, and he is determined to rape Fortune for his selfish ambitions.
Sensing that "something's rotten in the state of Denmark" and that his uncle's hasty marriage to his mother a month after the funeral hints of foul play, Hamlet's conscience urges him to seek justice and avenge the death of his father. King Hamlet's ghost keeps appearing to exhort the prince to do his moral duty. Hamlet, however, cannot merely trust the voice of the ghost, especially if it is a not an "honest" ghost but a demon from hell. Hamlet cannot wantonly kill Claudius at the slightest opportunity even though such a moment presents itself when the king appears contrite and in prayer. Hamlet cannot do evil to achieve good. He cannot assassinate the king, blindly trust the voice of the ghost, or commit suicide. Hamlet's Catholic conscience will not be violated. Revenge and despair are sins.
These immoral acts of revenge, rash judgment, and "self-slaughter" violate Christian teaching and debase Hamlet. In a quandary of self-examination and introspection Hamlet ponders the moral crisis he suffers. On the one hand, he feels hopeless weak, powerless, and insignificant. "To be honest, as this world goes is to be one man picked out of ten thousand," Hamlet agonizes. He regards himself as the victim of uncontrollable evil forces, "the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune," and his enemies at the court are legion. The king he suspects of treachery, his mother he accuses of weakness and folly, his lover Ophelia betrays him and spies for her father Polonius, and Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are convenient hirelings ready to escort Hamlet to his death. To use the phrases of Montaigne, Hamlet regards himself as impotent as "a feather in the wind" and as insignificant as "a dot made by a fine pencil." He suffers "The whips and scorns of time, / The oppressor's wrong, the proud man's contumely" that reduce him to nothing.
In the inevitable clash between these two world views, Claudius assumes he wields absolute control and holds Hamlet's life in his hands. Even though his first artful plot to have Hamlet executed in England is foiled by Hamlet's sleeplessness during the night when he awakes and "rashly" opens the packets with the order for his death ("And praised be rashness for it"), Claudius devises two other stratagems to eliminate Hamlet. For the diversion of the court he proposes a dueling match between Hamlet and Laertes, a contest in which Laertes' rapier is poisoned at the tip to deal a fatal blow from even the slightest scratch. Even more deviously Claudius also puts poison in the chalice of Hamlet's cup that he will drink for refreshment. For all his imaginary omniscience and infallibility Claudius, however, is not in total control of events despite his Machiavellian boldness and craftiness. In the skirmish between the two fencers, Laertes and Hamlet drop their swords and accidentally take the other's rapier. During the intermission Queen Gertrude randomly picks the poisoned chalice by mistake and begins drinking. In the aftermath of these unforeseen accidents and surprises, it is not only Hamlet who dies but also Claudius, Laertes, and Gertrude as Claudius' plots ensnare him. The king whose lethal weapon is poison is "hoist[ed] by his own petard." The scheming Claudius discovers that might is not right, man is not god, man does not dictate the future, and the end does not justify the means.
At the end of the play Hamlet is no longer reacting to events, passively suffering misfortunes, or submitting to despair but acting against them like the valiant prince he is — man created in God's image, not man as God or man as nothing but the true Christian image of man ...
As Hamlet discovered on board the ship to England when he acted on his suspicions and opened the secret letters, "Our indiscretion sometimes serves us well/ When our deep plots do pall; and that should learn us/ There's a divinity that shapes our ends,/ Rough-hew them how we will — ." Man is not just a passive victim of the formidable forces of evil or a feather in the wind subject to the the slings and arrows of Fortune. Hamlet, even though he is one man in ten thousand in a corrupt world, does God's will and cooperates with divine providence. One noble, heroic man transforms the rottenness in Denmark. As the final events of the play reveal, divine providence governs the world, not Fortune and not man. Hamlet does not do evil to achieve good but acts in good conscience, and God is the arbiter of life and death, not man.
When man acts with moral courage and seeks justice rather than revenge and when he suffers injustices rather than inflicting evil, he sees the hand of God. Because Hamlet miraculously escaped from death on the ship, he fearlessly returns to Denmark and boldly accepts Claudius's proposal for the fencing match, despite Horatio's warning of possible treachery ("You will lose, my lord"). In his hatred of evil and in his trust in Divine Providence, Hamlet does not fear death as he enters the fencing match: "We defy augury. There is a special providence in the fall of a sparrow. If it be not now, 'tis not to come; if it be not to come, it will be now; if it be not now, yet it will come. The readiness is all." At the end of the play Hamlet is no longer reacting to events, passively suffering misfortunes, or submitting to despair but acting against them like the valiant prince he is — man created in God's image, not man as God or man as nothing but the true Christian image of man Hamlet describes in his famous words: "What a piece of work is man! How noble in reason! How infinite in faculty! In form and moving how express and admirable! In action how like an angel."
Mitchell A. Kalpakgian. "Shakespeare's Hamlet." Crisis Magazine (March 14, 2013).
Reprinted with permission of Crisis Magazine.
Crisis Magazine is an educational apostolate that uses media and technology to bring the genius of Catholicism to business, politics, culture, and family life. Our approach is oriented toward the practical solutions our faith offers — in other words, actionable Catholicism.
The AuthorMitchell A. Kalpakgian was Professor of English at Simpson College (Iowa) for 31 years. During his academic career, Dr. Kalpakgian received many academic honors, among them the National Endowment for the Humanities Summer Seminar Fellowship (Brown University, 1981); the Andrew W. Mellon Fellowship (University of Kansas, 1985); and an award from the National Endowment for the Humanities Institute on Children's Literature. He is the author of The Marvelous in Fielding's Novels and The Mysteries of Life in Children's Literature. His favorite activities include writing, long distance running, and coaching soccer.Copyright © 2013 Crisis Magazine
back to top