A patron saint for the disappointed

It should be remembered that his achievements, for the most part, hardly seemed successful at the time.  He might even be called a patron saint of the disappointed.

Newman was so nervous in his university examinations that he got a “Lower Second Class” degree.  He played the violin to relax, but the chords of his mind were taut, and he later suffered a nervous breakdown.  He failed to attain a professorship of Moral Philosophy.  Many Oxford dons derided his views, and eventually he resigned.

When Newman became a Catholic, former friends thought he had wasted his talents, and some Catholics questioned his free spirit and innovative genius.  Not least among these were bishops.  In Ireland, Archbishop Cullen impeded his foundation of a Catholic University there and opposed making Newman a bishop.  In England, Cardinal Manning, a great man in some ways but not innocent of envy, regularly thwarted numerous projects.  The English-language secretary of Pope Pius IX prejudiced the pope’s opinion of Newman, and with no little subtlety, Manning tried to prevent the new Pope Leo XIII from vindicating him with a Cardinal’s red hat.

Newman left a legacy of 32 volumes of letters, and in some of them he confided his frustrations.  But his amiability and patience won over many.  In old age, Newman’s Oxford college made him an honorary Fellow, and at Newman’s death Manning himself said, “The history of our land will hereafter record the name of John Henry Newman among the greatest of our people, as a confessor for the faith, a great teacher of men, a preacher of justice, of piety, and of compassion.”

Neman kept his balance by a steady faith in the uncompromising truth of Christ.  This boldly defied the pastiche of true Christianity that was spreading in his time and which he prophesied would become endemic in our own age:

What is the world's religion now?  It has taken the brighter side of the gospel, its tidings of comfort, its precepts of love; all darker, deeper views of man's condition and prospects being comparatively forgotten.  This is the religion natural to a civilized age and well has Satan dressed and completed it into an idol of the Truth. . . . Our manners are courteous; we avoid giving pain or offence . . . religion is pleasant and easy; benevolence is the chief virtue; intolerance, bigotry, excess of zeal are the first of sins. . . . [I]t includes no true fear of God, no fervent zeal for His honour, no deep hatred of sin, no horror at the sight of sinners, no indignation and compassion at the blasphemy of heretics, no jealous adherence to doctrinal truth . . .— and therefore is neither hot nor cold, but (in Scripture language) lukewarm.  (Sermon 24. Religion of the Day)

That sort of “Catholic-Lite” does not make saints, and Newman proved that.