Menu
A+ A A-

Careerism and vanity: Sins of the Church

  • ANDREA TORNIELLI

The Cardinal Archbishop of Buenos Aires (now Pope Francis), spoke to Vatican Insider in February, 2012.

Bergoglio1.jpg
Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio
Archbishop of Buenos Aires

During the recent Consistory that was held in the midst of the controversy regarding the documents that were leaked from the Vatican Secretary of State, Benedict XVI wanted cardinals to talk about the new evangelisation.  He reminded cardinals about the spirit of service and the importance of humility. The Archbishop of Buenos Aires, Jorge Mario Bergoglio, a Jesuit of Turinese origin, is a prominent figure within the Latin American Episcopate.  In his diocese, Buenos Aires, the Church has, for quite some time now, been going out into the streets, squares and stations to evangelise and administer the sacraments.  Vatican Insider interviewed the archbishop, asking him to comment on the discussions that took place during the Consistory and on the Pope's words.


Vatican Insider:   What do you make of the Pope's decision to call for a year of faith and his insistence on the new evangelisation?

Archbishop Bergoglio:  "Benedict XVI has insisted on the renewal of faith being a priority and presents faith as a gift that must be passed on, a gift to be offered to others and to be shared as a gratuitous act.  It is not a possession, but a mission.  This priority indicated by the Pope has a commemorative purpose:  through the Year of Faith we remember the gift we have received.  And there are three pillars to this: the memory of having been chosen, the memory of the promise that was made to us and the alliance that God has forged with us.  We are called to renew this alliance, our belonging to the community of God's faithful."


Vatican Insider:   What does evangelisation mean in a context such as that of Latin America?

Archbishop Bergoglio:  "The context is that which emerged from the fifth conference of Latin American bishops, held in Aparecida, in 2007.  It called us to undertake a continental mission, the entire continent is a missionary state. Plans were and continue to be made, but the paradigmatic aspect remains:  all ordinary activities of the Church take place in view of the mission.  This signifies very strong tensions between centre and periphery, between parish and district.  We need to come out of ourselves and head for the periphery.  We need to avoid the spiritual sickness of a Church that is wrapped up in its own world:  when a Church becomes like this, it grows sick.  It is true that going out onto the street implies the risk of accidents happening, as they would to any ordinary man or woman.  But is the Church stays wrapped up in itself, it will age.  And if I had to choose between a wounded Church that goes out onto the streets and a sick withdrawn Church, I would definitely choose the first one."


Vatican Insider:   What is your experience of this in Argentina and in Buenos Aires in particular?

We need to come out of ourselves and head for the periphery. We need to avoid the spiritual sickness of a Church that is wrapped up in its own world:  when a Church becomes like this, it grows sick.

Archbishop Bergoglio:  "We seek to make contact with families that are not involved in the parish.  Instead of just being a Church that welcomes and receives, we try to be a Church that comes out of itself and goes to the men and women who do not participate in parish life, do not know much about it and are indifferent towards it.  We organise missions in public squares where many people usually gather: we pray, we celebrate mass, we offer baptism which we administer after a brief preparation.  This is the style of the parishes and the diocese itself.  Other than this, we also try to reach out to people who are far away, via digital means, the web and brief messaging."


Vatican Insider:   In his speech during the Consistory and in his homily on Sunday 19th February, the Pope stressed the fact that the cardinalate is a service and that the Church cannot build itself.  What are your thoughts on Benedict XVI's words?

Archbishop Bergoglio:  "I was struck by the imagery evoked by the Pope, who talked about James and John and the tensions between the first followers of Jesus on who should be first. This shows us that certain attitudes and arguments have existed in the Church since the beginning.  And this should not shock us.  The cardinalate is a service is, it is not an award to be bragged about.  Vanity, showing off, is an attitude that reduces spirituality to a worldly thing, which is the worst sin that could be committed in the Church.  This is affirmed in the final pages of the book entitled Méditation sur l'Église, by Henri De Lubac.  Spiritual worldliness is a form of religious anthropocentrism that has Gnostic elements.  Careerism and the search for a promotion come under the category of spiritual worldliness.  An example I often use to illustrate the reality of vanity, is this:  look at the peacock; it's beautiful if you look at it from the front. But if you look at it from behind, you discover the truth ... Whoever gives in to such self-absorbed vanity has huge misery hiding inside them."


Vatican Insider:   What does a cardinal's role really involve then?

Archbishop Bergoglio:  "Cardinals are not NGO representatives, but servants of the Lord, inspired by the Holy Spirit, which is the One who is really able to differentiate charismas, unifying them in the Church.  A cardinal must be able to difference between charismas and at the same time look towards unity.  Aware that the creator of difference and unity is the Holy Spirit itself.  Cardinals who do not enter this frame of mind, in my view, are not cardinals in the way Benedict XVI would like them to be."


Vatican Insider:   This Consistory was held at a difficult and tense time in light of the Vatican document leak.  How do the Pope's words help us to view this reality?

I must not be scandalised by the fact that the Church is my mother:  I must look at its sin and shortcomings as I would look at my mother's sins and shortcomings.  And when I think of her, I remember the good and beautiful things she has achieved, more than her weaknesses and defects.

Archbishop Bergoglio:  "Benedict XVI's words help us to live this reality form the point of view of conversion.  I liked the fact that the last Consistory was held on the threshold of Lent.  It is an invitation to look at the Church, holy and sinful as it is, to look at certain shortcomings and sins, without losing sight of the holiness of so many men and women who work in the Church today.  I must not be scandalised by the fact that the Church is my mother:  I must look at its sin and shortcomings as I would look at my mother's sins and shortcomings.  And when I think of her, I remember the good and beautiful things she has achieved, more than her weaknesses and defects.  A mother defends herself with a heart filled with love before doing so with words.  I wonder whether there is any love for the Church in the hearts of those who pay so much attention to the scandals.


Vatican Insider:   Can you tell us show the Roman Curia is perceived from the outside?

Archbishop Bergoglio:  "I see it as a body that gives service, a body that helps me and serves me.  Sometimes negative news does come out, but it is often exaggerated and manipulated to spread scandal.  Journalists sometimes risk becoming ill from coprophilia and thus fomenting coprophagia: which is a sin that taints all men and women, that is, the tendency to focus on the negative rather than the positive aspects.  The Roman Curia has its down sides, but I think that too much emphasis is placed on its negative aspects and not enough on the holiness of the numerous consecrated and lay people who work in it."

dividertop

Acknowledgement

Andrea Tornielli. "Careerism and vanity: Sins of the Church." Vatican Insider (February 24, 2012).

Reprinted with permission from Vatican Insider.

Vatican Insider is a project run by the daily newspaper La Stampa, designed to provide a complete information service on the Vatican, the activities of the Pope and the Holy See, the Catholic Church's presence on the international scene and on religious issues. It is an independent multimedia tool, produced in three languages: Italian, English and Spanish. It is distributed through the website www.VaticanInsider.com, as well as other digital platforms and the main social networks on the Internet. It boasts a staff of qualified Vatican correspondents, flanked by some of the most prestigious international names in the field of religious and Vatican-based information.

The Author

Andrea Tornielli is a reporter and journalist for the Italian daily newspaper La Stampa. He is the author of many books, including: Carlo Maria Martini: Il profeta del dialogo, Pio IX. L'ultimo papa re (Oscar storia), A.D. 2012: La donna, il drago e l'Apocalisse, Il futuro e la speranza: Vita e magistero del cardinale Angelo Scola, and Paolo VI: L'audacia di un papa.

Copyright © 2012 Vatican Insider
back to top