DogmatismMORTIMER J. ADLER
In philosophy dogmatism is totally inappropriate.
In philosophy, however, dogmatism is totally inappropriate. Everything that is asserted or denied must be submitted to rational inquiry that seeks to establish it with certitude or probability.
There are some philosophical positions the affirmation of which are beyond the power of reason to establish. An example is the main thesis of ontological materialism, that nothing really exists except bodies and their physical transformations. That thesis, being a denial, therefore is a negation, and as such it is indemonstrable.
Most of the contemporary scientists and professors of philosophy who embrace materialism unquestioningly do so without a logical qualm. They mistakenly think that the evidence of their senses tells them that all observable phenomena are physical. Of course this is correct, but it does not prove that only observable phenomena are real. There is no evidence that reality does not and cannot include the immaterial and the nonphysical. To assert that it does not and cannot is sheer dogmatism, of a kind that should be avoided in philosophy.
Mortimer J. Adler. "Dogmatism." excerpt from Adler's Philosophical Dictionary: 125 Key Terms for the Philosopher's Lexicon (New York: Touchstone, 1996): 80-81.
Reprinted courtesy of the Center for the Study of Great Ideas.
Ongoing programs started or developed by Dr. Adler include: The Great Books Foundation (with Robert Hutchins), the Basic Program of Liberal Education for Adults at the University of Chicago (with Robert Hutchins), the Executive Seminars of The Aspen Institute, the Paideia Project (a plan for major reform of public school education), and The Great Ideas seminars at the Center for the Study of The Great Ideas — all promoting liberal education through an understanding of great works of philosophy, literature, history, science, and religion. He was the author of over 50 books, including Adler's Philosophical Dictionary: 125 Key Terms for the Philosopher's Lexicon, How to Read a Book, How to Speak/How to Listen, How to Think About The Great Ideas, and Aristotle for Everybody.
Copyright © 1996 Mortimer Adler
Not all articles published on CERC are the objects of official Church teaching, but these are supplied to provide supplementary information.