A Secular Apocalypse: A review of the movie 2012FATHER ROBERT BARRON
A wise professor of mine, Msgr. Robert Sokolowski, once commented that, with the rise of Protestantism and modernity, an integrated Catholicism blew up and its twisted pieces now litter the contemporary intellectual landscape.
The notion of a world-ending catastrophe is, of course, Biblical. We hear of it in the story of Noah's ark; it is predicted in the book of the prophet Daniel, and it is prominently featured in the book of Revelation, which brings the Bible to a close. There are two great sources for this religious intuition of the endtimes. First, we all know in our bones that the world is radically contingent, that it does not contain within itself the reason for its own existence. Things are, but they don't have to be; they carry within themselves the heritage of non-being, and therefore, they are fragile, susceptible to destruction. The other inspiration for the apocalyptic is a keen sense of sin. We know that all of us are sinners and that our wicked ways have infected everything: institutions, political systems, families, societies, and cultures. And therefore, we feel that the world is under judgment and awaits a cleansing. It is important to note that both of these intuitions are tightly correlated to belief in God. The very continkgency of the universe points to the existence of a non-contingent reality that sustains the fragile world in being, and the sinfulness of humanity is understood only in reference to some absolute criterion of good.
What we see in Emmerich's film is a secular apocalypse, a re-telling of the Biblical story, but without God or any transcendent reference. In fact, God is not simply absent; he is aggressively eliminated. As the world falls apart, a number of people in "2012" turn to God in prayer, but they are, without exception, destroyed. A Hindu scientist, whose research first uncovered the coming apocalypse, folds his hands to pray, just before a tidal wave overwhelms him and his family. The President of the United States stays behind in the White House to invoke God's help while the rest of the government is shuttled off to the ships. He goes on television to inform the country of the dire situation, and he invites them to recite Psalm 23, but when he comes to the line, "the Lord is my shepherd, I shall not want," the communication is abruptly severed. The Cardinals of the Catholic Church kneel in ardent prayer in the Sistine Chapel, and just before the building collapses on them, they witness a great fissure running across the ceiling, passing directly between the fingers of God and Adam, separating divinity and humanity. And in a scene that will go down in the annals of cinematic anti-Catholicism, the Pope himself leads prayers from the loggia of St. Peter's, while a huge throng looks on. The dome of the basilica totters, falls, and then rolls over thousands in the square below! Just in case we miss the point, Emmerich shows us the famous statue of Christ, which stands majestically on a hilltop overlooking Rio de Janeiro, crumbling to pieces.
Meanwhile, none of those who are making their way to the arks ever reference God. There is much talk of science and compassion and the preservation of culture, but no one in this group prays, or speculates theologically on the unfolding calamity. (There is one religion that seems to meet with the director's approval: a young Buddhist monk manages to shepherd his family on board one of the arks. But of course, Buddhism is a non-theistic religion. Buddhists hold that ultimate reality is not a creative and provident God, but rather the interdependent co-origination of all things).
In time, the worst of the crisis passes, and we see the arks making their way through placid seas, while on the screen there appears the new date: Year One. This is a fantasy that goes back at least as far as the French Revolution: once the old world has been cleansed of religion, people can let go of the antiquated dating system that commences with the birth of Christ. We then hear that the only continent that didn't suffer inordinately from the apocalyptic meltdown was Africa; in fact, the scientists announce, it has arisen and its people preserved. Now say what you want about this, but what struck me was a certain unintentional irony: the continent where Christianity, and specifically Catholic Christianity, is growing most vigorously today, is not Europe or North America, but Africa. As the band of noble secularists arrives at the promised land, they will be met, not by Euro-skeptics, but by millions upon millions of Christians!
By the way, if you harbor any doubts as to whether I'm imagining all of this anti-religious sentiment, take a look at Roland Emmerich's biography. I'll give you one tidbit: in his house, he has a life-sized statue of John Paul II, laughing while he reads his own obituary. So don't see this film. Instead, read the book of Revelation. It's, of course, theologically richer, and also much less boring.
Father Robert Barron, "A Secular Apocalypse: A review of the movie 2012." Word On Fire (November 25, 2009).
Reprinted with permission of Father Robert Barron.
Fr. Robert Barron was ordained a priest for the Archdiocese of Chicago in 1986. He has a Masters degree in Philosophy from the Catholic University of America and a Doctorate in Sacred Theology from the Institute Catholique de Paris. He is currently professor of systematic theology at the University of St. Mary of the Lake, Mundelein Seminary. Fr. Barron is the author of, And Now I See: A Theology of Transformation, Thomas Aquinas: Spiritual Master, Heaven in Stone and Glass: Experiencing the Spirituality of the Great Cathedrals, Eucharist (Catholic Spirituality for Adults), Priority of Christ, The: Toward a Postliberal Catholicism, and Word on File: Proclaiming the Power of Christ. He also gives frequent talks, retreats and workshops on issues of theology and spirituality.
Father Barron uses his YouTube channel to reach out to people and bring valuable lessons of faith alive by pointing out things that can be learned by watching popular characters of movies and television shows.
Copyright © 2009 Father Robert Barron
Not all articles published on CERC are the objects of official Church teaching, but these are supplied to provide supplementary information.