We cannot avoid making judgments

BISHOP DAVID MCGOUGH

When we avoid a rush to destructive judgment and accusation we allow the possibility that the good within us might ultimately flourish and come to fruition.

'But you, God of mercy and compassion, slow to anger, O Lord, abounding in love and truth, turn and take pity on me."  Today's responsorial psalm, with its appeal to a God of mercy and compassion, leads on from the description of God's judgment in the Book of Wisdom.  It is perhaps only natural that we who know our own frailty only too well should banish from our consciousness the thought of judgment.  If we doubt this, then we should gauge our own reaction to criticism of any kind.  We are indeed fortunate if foolish pride does not obscure the judgment that we truly deserve.

The Book of Wisdom speaks to our instinctive fear of judgment.  The God who judges us is not our enemy.  He is the one who cares for all that he has created.  His overwhelming judgment is reserved for those who stubbornly ignore his presence, whose insolent persistence in wrongdoing is a denial of his goodness.  For others, who long for his presence despite their failings, he is mild in judgment and governs with great leniency.

The author of the Book of Wisdom takes this understanding of God's judgment as a model for our dealings with each other.  "By acting thus you have taught a lesson to your people, how the virtuous man must be kindly to his fellow men, and you have given your sons the good hope that after sin you will grant repentance."


We cannot avoid making judgments in daily life, but such judgment should always be tempered by the mercy we ourselves hope to receive.  In a world of instant communication, it is only too easy to be drawn into a frenzy of judgment that knows nothing of mercy and compassion and that leaves no possibility for repentance.  In the parables of the Kingdom Jesus described ourselves, as individuals, and as a Church, as a work in progress.  As such, we are a mixture of good and bad.  Despite our many failings, there is hidden within us all a God-given capacity for good.  In the attitudes that govern our relationships to family, parish and Church, we should be guided by the understanding expressed in familiar parables.  Jesus described the Church as a field initially sown with good seed, but subsequently contaminated by the darnel that had been sown by an enemy. 

For others, who long for his presence despite their failings, he is mild in judgment and governs with great leniency.

We cannot deny, either in ourselves or in the Church, that the perfect and the imperfect flourish side by side.  What was so distinctive in the teaching of Jesus was the manner in which he understood this situation.  There was to be no destructive rush to judgment.  The labourers were not to weed out the darnel, lest in their zeal they destroyed the whole field.  "Let them both grow till the harvest, and at harvest I will say to the reapers: first collect the darnel to be burnt, then gather the wheat into my barn."

When we avoid a rush to destructive judgment and accusation we allow the possibility that the good within us might ultimately flourish and come to fruition.  Vindictive judgment, as history demonstrates, frequently destroys the good for which we strive. 

Let us respect each other as those who, despite our many failings, bear within ourselves the mustard seed, the hidden leaven of God's presence. 

 

 



ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

Bishop David McGough. "We cannot avoid making judgments, but judgment should always be tempered by mercy." The Catholic Herald (July 17, 2014).

Reprinted with permission of The Catholic Herald, the UK's leading traditionalist weekly. The Catholic Herald serves 65,000+ mass-attenders and much of the clergy every Sunday. It provides readers with in-depth news coverage, rigorous analysis of the Faith, spiritual reflection, features and comment by some of our sharpest Catholic thinkers, and studies the path taken by the Church in Britain and Ireland today

Subscribe to the The Catholic Herald here.

THE AUTHOR

Bishop David McGough is an Auxiliary Bishop in Birmingham, England. Bishop McGough spent 15 years teaching Scripture to students for the Catholic Priesthood at Oscott College from 1974 until 1989. In 1986 he was appointed as Parish Priest at Christ the King, Kingstanding, Birmingham. He has been Parish Priest at Our Lady and All Saints, Stourbridge, since 1990. He was appointed Episcopal Vicar for Walsall, Wolverhampton, the Black Country and Worcestershire in 2004. His hobbies are photography and heritage railways. He follows Stoke City Football Club from a distance.

Copyright © 2014 The Catholic Herald




Subscribe to CERC's Weekly E-Letter

 

 

Not all articles published on CERC are the objects of official Church teaching, but these are supplied to provide supplementary information.